Juvenile District Judge, 313th Judicial District
Samantha Y. Davis
Democrat
Philosophy
What is your philosophy on juvenile justice, and how do you balance accountability with rehabilitation for young people who appear before your court, including your approach to diversion programs and alternatives to detention?
My philosophy on juvenile justice is to protect the community while giving young people the opportunity to learn from their mistakes and become productive citizens. Accountability and rehabilitation should work together. I believe each case should be evaluated individually, considering the child’s circumstances, family support, and underlying needs. When appropriate and consistent with public safety, I support diversion programs and evidence-based alternatives to detention, including counseling, mentoring, education, and treatment services. Detention should be reserved for cases where it is necessary to protect the community, the child or to ensure a child’s appearance in court.
Alternatives
What, if any, alternatives to detention do you support for juvenile offenders? Please discuss program options, as well as when and how such alternatives can be used.
I support evidence-based alternatives to detention when they are consistent with public safety and appropriate under the law. These include diversion programs, counseling, mentoring, restorative justice, substance abuse and mental health treatment, educational support, and community service. These programs can address the root causes of delinquent behavior while holding youth accountable. Detention should be reserved for cases where it is necessary to protect the community or ensure a juvenile’s appearance in court. Every decision should be made on a case-by-case basis, considering the child’s needs, risk level, and the safety of the community.
